5 Signs Your Payroll System is Holding You Back 

The last quarter of the year can feel chaotic for small business owners. Tasks are piling up, year-end reporting is looming, and it’s tempting to stick with what you know just to get through. But this is also the time many stop to ask: is it time to switch payroll providers? Staying in your comfort zone can backfire, especially when it comes to payroll.

Here’s the thing: there’s a difference between a payroll system that’s efficient and one that’s just familiar. If it’s clunky, time-consuming or stressful, that pain will follow you into 2026. If you feel this way, you’re not alone: research shows that 1 in 4 businesses worldwide switch payroll providers every year, often to simplify tax season and start the new year with more confidence. Reviewing your systems now can help improve operations, reduce errors, and make year-end feel much less like a paperwork circus. 

Here are five signs it might be time to switch payroll providers.

1. Payroll eats up hours you don’t have

Manual entries, spreadsheets, and double-checking numbers is not only frustrating, but time-consuming. Even with software, payroll can take hours if the process is complicated or requires repetitive steps, constant verification, or juggling multiple tools to get everything right. 

The best way to win back that time is with payroll software that’s actually simple to use. For small business owners, that means:

• Clear, guided steps so you always know what to do next
• Automation that handles calculations, deductions, taxes and remittances
• Integration with time tracking or accounting tools, so you’re not re-entering data
• Auto-run payroll, so paydays run themselves without any extra clicks
• Simple, relevant features. No bloated add-ons you’ll never use

2. Fixing payroll errors is your second job

Payroll isn’t just math. It’s laws, deadlines, and changing rules. From CRA remittances to vacation pay and CPP2, compliance headaches are a big reason businesses outgrow their current system. A single payroll error costs Canadian employers an average of $291 per mistake, which can add up over multiple employees and pay periods. More than that, it can cost you hours to fix. 

The Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) found that Canadian businesses spend more than 700 hours a year on regulatory compliance, much of which is tied to payroll, remittances, and tax filings. That’s nearly 18 weeks of full-time work that could be spent on growing your business instead.

The right payroll system helps you stay accurate and compliant by offering: 

• Automatic tax updates so you’re always in step with CRA rules and provincial regulations.
• Built-in CRA remittances and year-end forms
• Error alerts and adjustment tools to quickly spot and correct errors
• Clear audit trails that show exactly what happened and when

3. Your payroll system feels like it’s stuck in the past

Listening to ‘90s playlists? Cool. Running payroll on software that feels like it still needs a dial-up modem to connect? Not so cool.

If your current system has a clunky interface or slow processing times, it’s time to upgrade and switch payroll providers. Outdated payroll systems run slower, crash more often, and create extra stress every payday. They’re also more vulnerable to security risks, since older software often misses critical updates or can’t be updated at all. And when your team dreads logging in because the user experience is so frustrating, payroll will take even longer than it should. It’s a drain on your time, your focus, and your peace of mind.

What to look for in a modern payroll system:

• Cloud-based access so you can run payroll securely from anywhere
• Fast, reliable processing that doesn’t crash or freeze
• A user-friendly design that feels intuitive
• Modern security features like bank-grade encryption, role-based access controls and two-factor authentication (2FA) for extra secure log-ins

4.  You’re dreading year-end reporting

Year-end is always busy, but it doesn’t have to be stressful. Reconciling payroll, generating and distributing T4s and T4As, and double-checking deductions can quickly turn into hours of work, especially if your system isn’t designed to make it easy.  And when reports are hard to read or key information is missing, it’s even harder to stay ahead, leaving you scrambling at the last minute.

Switch payroll providers to one with features that make year-end easier:

• Automated year-end forms, including T4s and T4As
• Integrated remittances. Automatically calculate and manage final CPP, EI, and tax remittances as part of your year-end process
• Accurate YTD reports that are easy to review at high-level
• A guided year-end process that includes clear steps, how-tos, timelines and reminders so that nothing gets overlooked
• An employee self-service portal where they can securely access their tax forms, so you don’t have to distribute them by hand or mail

5. Support isn’t very supportive

When questions or issues come up, you want answers from people who actually understand payroll and the challenges of running a small business. Without fast, expert support, even simple issues can snowball into hours of frustration and delays.

Here’s what great payroll support looks like: 

• Friendly, guided onboarding to get you started right
• Multiple support channels, including phone, chat, or email, during your working hours
• No premium fees for accessing support
• Canadian-based payroll experts who understand local payroll rules, CRA requirements, and time zones

Time to switch payroll providers? 

If any of these signs sound familiar, your payroll system may be doing more harm than good. But you don’t have to put up with clunky software, endless errors or year-end headaches. With Wagepoint, payroll is simple, accurate and built for Canadian small businesses. From auto-run paydays to built-on year-end forms, we have you covered.

Ready to see the difference? Start your free Wagepoint trial.

Written by Kasia Wind

Kasia Wind is a Strategic Communications and Content Marketing Manager at Wagepoint. As a kid, she wanted to become a talk show host like Jenny Jones (it didn't work out). A believer that storytelling is the best way to connect, Kasia has created content for audiences including small businesses, bodybuilders and doctors. Oddly, her own stories often involve getting injured in hilarious ways.

More content from author